1. What Determines TEV Report Fees in India
TEV report fees are rarely decided by a standard rate card.
The fee generally depends on what the assignment involves, how much information
needs to be reviewed, the nature of the project, and what the lender expects
from the final report.
A Techno Economic Viability report is not simply a financial
projection prepared from figures supplied by the promoter. For a proper
assessment, the consultant may need to examine the project concept, technical
configuration, installed capacity, machinery, raw materials, utilities, project
cost, means of finance, operating assumptions, market conditions, projected
revenues, expenses, cash flows, debt servicing capacity, and several other
aspects.
This is why two companies asking for a TEV report can
receive very different quotations.
Consider an established manufacturing company planning to
add another production line to an existing plant. The consultant may already
have access to operating data, historical financial statements, machinery
quotations and production information. The assignment may be relatively
straightforward.
Now consider a new greenfield industrial project where land
acquisition is still being completed, machinery suppliers have provided
different quotations, capacity assumptions are under discussion and the
promoter is approaching a consortium of lenders. The amount of work is
considerably higher. The TEV report also has to withstand closer scrutiny.
The same principle applies to solar projects, hospitals,
warehouses, infrastructure projects and other capital intensive ventures.
TEV report fees therefore need to be viewed in relation to
the scope of work rather than simply as a professional charge.
Banks also have a reason for commissioning or relying on a
TEV assessment. A lender wants an independent view of whether the proposed
project makes technical and economic sense and whether the assumptions
supporting repayment are reasonable.
A promoter may be convinced that a project can generate
strong returns. The lender has to test that belief.
That difference in perspective is important.
2. Why TEV Report Fees Vary From Project to Project
There is a common expectation among promoters that a TEV
report should have a fixed price because the name of the report is the same. In
practice, the assignment behind the report can be completely different.
A small capacity expansion and a large greenfield project
cannot be assessed with the same level of effort.
For example, suppose an MSME has an existing engineering
unit and wants term finance for new machinery. The consultant may need to study
the existing operations, proposed expansion, machinery quotations, incremental
production, additional working capital and projected debt servicing.
Compare that with a hospital project where the promoter is
setting up a new multi speciality facility. Here, the assessment may involve
construction costs, medical equipment, bed capacity, occupancy assumptions,
staffing, departments, tariffs, operating expenses, location considerations and
the financing structure.
The report may be considerably more involved.
Solar projects provide another useful example. A lender
evaluating a solar project may be interested in generation assumptions, plant
capacity, equipment selection, project cost, evacuation arrangements, power
sale arrangements, operating expenses and debt repayment. The commercial
structure can also influence the assessment.
So when someone asks about TEV report fees, the better
question is usually, "What exactly does the assignment require?"
Some of the factors that can change the professional fee
include:
|
Factor |
Why it matters |
|
Project size |
Larger investments usually require more detailed
assessment |
|
Project type |
Manufacturing, solar, healthcare and infrastructure have
different technical considerations |
|
Greenfield or expansion |
Existing operations provide more historical information |
|
Financial complexity |
Multiple funding sources and complicated debt structures
require additional analysis |
|
Site assessment |
Physical or operational verification can add to the
assignment |
|
Lender requirements |
Specific lender formats and additional analysis may
increase the scope |
|
Data availability |
Poor or incomplete information often requires more
clarification and validation |
|
Number of locations |
Multiple sites can make the assignment more time consuming |
|
Project stage |
A concept stage project may need more assumption testing
than a mature project |
This does not mean a higher fee automatically means a better
report. It means the scope needs to be understood before comparing quotations.
I have seen cases where promoters focus heavily on saving a
relatively small professional fee and later spend much more time correcting
inconsistencies between the DPR, financial model, machinery quotations and
information submitted to the bank. That is frustrating because the problem
could often have been avoided at the beginning.
3. Key Factors That Influence TEV Report Fees
Several elements usually determine the amount of
professional work required for a TEV assignment.
Nature of the project
A simple expansion of an existing unit is different from a
new infrastructure project.
A manufacturing project may require analysis of production
capacity, machinery, raw materials, power requirements and manufacturing costs.
A real estate development may involve construction schedules, sales
assumptions, approvals, project costs and cash flows.
The technical and commercial questions change with the
sector.
Project cost
Project cost is another practical consideration. A ₹10 crore
project and a ₹500 crore project may require very different levels of analysis.
This is not because the fee should simply be calculated as a
percentage of project cost. Professional fees are generally linked more closely
to the scope and complexity of work. However, larger projects tend to involve
more assumptions, more stakeholders, more documentation and greater lender
scrutiny.
Greenfield versus expansion
An existing business has historical financial statements,
production records, customer information and operating history.
A new project does not have this advantage.
For a greenfield project, the consultant has to rely more
heavily on market assumptions, technical proposals, cost estimates and promoter
inputs. Those assumptions need to be examined carefully because there is no
operating history to compare against.
This often affects TEV report fees.
Financial structure
The financing arrangement can also influence the assignment.
Suppose a promoter is arranging ₹50 crore of term debt from
one bank. The financial analysis may be relatively direct.
Now consider a ₹300 crore project involving multiple
lenders, promoter contribution, term debt, working capital limits, possibly
external funding and different repayment conditions. The assessment becomes
more detailed.
Debt servicing, interest assumptions, repayment schedules,
project cash flows and sensitivity analysis need to be consistent.
Quality of available information
This is often underestimated.
If the promoter provides an organised DPR, audited financial
statements, machinery quotations, land documents, production details, projected
financials and other relevant information, the consultant can spend more time
analysing the project.
If information arrives in fragments, with changing figures
and contradictory assumptions, considerable time may be spent clarifying basic
facts.
Sometimes the report itself is not the difficult part.
Getting reliable information in the right sequence is.
Requirement for site visit or technical verification
Some assignments may require a site visit or discussions
with the project team.
For an operating manufacturing unit, physical understanding
of the plant, machinery and proposed expansion can be useful.
For a warehouse project, the consultant may need to
understand the location, construction stage, proposed capacity and operational
arrangement.
Where field visits or additional verification are part of
the scope, this can affect TEV report fees.
Lender specific requirements
Banks and financial institutions do not always ask for
identical information.
One lender may require a standard TEV assessment. Another
may ask for additional sensitivity analysis, technical verification or
clarification of particular project assumptions.
A report prepared for a significant lending decision has to
address the questions that matter to the lender.
4. TEV Report Fees for Manufacturing and Industrial
Projects
Manufacturing projects are among the assignments where the
difference in scope can become particularly visible.
Take a company manufacturing auto components. It has been
operating for several years and now wants to install additional CNC machines to
increase capacity.
The consultant may examine:
- Existing
production and capacity utilisation
- Proposed
additional capacity
- Machinery
quotations
- Raw
material requirements
- Power
and utility requirements
- Incremental
manpower
- Manufacturing
costs
- Expected
selling prices
- Existing
customers and market demand
- Working
capital requirements
- Projected
profitability
- Debt
servicing ability
The assessment is not limited to asking whether the new
machines will increase production. The real question is whether the additional
investment makes commercial sense and whether the resulting cash generation is
sufficient for the proposed borrowing.
Now change the situation.
A promoter wants to establish a completely new
pharmaceutical manufacturing facility. Land, building, utilities, plant and
machinery, regulatory requirements, production capacity, product mix and market
assumptions all have to be examined.
The level of analysis can be much greater.
This is one reason it is difficult to give a meaningful
universal figure for TEV report fees without knowing the project.
An industrial borrower may also approach a consultant during
a restructuring situation. In that case, the question is not simply whether a
new project is viable. The assessment may need to consider existing debt,
operational performance, repayment obligations, future cash generation and the
proposed restructuring arrangement.
That is a different assignment altogether.
For MSMEs, another issue frequently appears. The promoter
may prepare a project cost based on initial quotations, but by the time the
proposal reaches the bank, machinery prices, construction costs or working
capital assumptions may have changed.
A TEV assessment can bring these inconsistencies into focus.
The purpose is not to make the report look complicated. It
is to give the lender a reasonable basis for understanding the project.
5. How Project Size and Complexity Affect TEV Report Fees
Project size matters, but complexity often matters more.
A ₹100 crore project with a straightforward structure and
reliable information may be easier to assess than a smaller project with
several locations, uncertain assumptions and complicated financing.
This is particularly relevant when comparing TEV report fees
from different consultants.
A promoter should not compare only the quoted amount. It is
better to compare what each consultant is actually agreeing to examine.
For example:
|
Assignment characteristic |
Likely impact on scope |
|
Existing unit expansion |
Usually simpler |
|
New manufacturing facility |
More detailed technical and financial assessment |
|
Large infrastructure project |
Higher complexity and stakeholder involvement |
|
Solar project with structured financing |
Detailed technical and commercial analysis |
|
Hospital project |
Multiple operating and financial assumptions |
|
Multiple project locations |
Additional review and coordination |
|
Consortium or multiple lenders |
Greater documentation and financial analysis |
|
Restructuring case |
Historical and future debt assessment |
|
Incomplete project information |
More clarification and validation work |
Project complexity can also increase when the promoter has
ambitious assumptions.
Suppose a new factory is projected to reach 90 percent
capacity utilisation very quickly. The consultant cannot simply insert that
figure into the financial model because it was provided by management.
The assumption needs to be considered against the nature of
the industry, production ramp up, market demand, sales arrangements and
operating capabilities.
Similarly, projected selling prices need some commercial
logic behind them. Raw material costs, employee expenses, utilities,
maintenance and working capital cannot be treated as arbitrary numbers.
This is where the experience of the consultant becomes
relevant.
A technically correct spreadsheet can still represent a weak
project if the assumptions behind it are unrealistic.
Many business owners believe that if the DPR is prepared
properly, the bank loan will automatically follow. I disagree with that view. A
DPR is an important part of a funding proposal, but credit appraisal considers
much more than the report itself. Existing financial performance, promoter
contribution, collateral, repayment capacity, banking conduct, project
viability and the lender's internal policies can all influence the decision.
At the same time, I might be wrong here if someone is
dealing with a lender or scheme where the documentation requirements are
unusually limited. This doesn't apply everywhere.
Frontline Consultants works on assignments where the
requirement can extend beyond preparing a document. Its financial and project
advisory work includes Techno Economic Viability Reports, Lenders Independent
Engineer Services, Agency for Special Monitoring, Detailed Project Reports,
Enterprise Valuation, Asset Valuation, Credit Syndication, Debt Restructuring,
Bank Liaison, Project Advisory and Business Financial Consulting.
For a promoter considering a TEV assignment, the practical
starting point is therefore not "What is the cheapest TEV report?"
It is "What does my lender actually need, and what
level of assessment does my project require?"
That question usually gives a much clearer basis for
discussing TEV report fees.
6. What Is Usually Covered in TEV Report Fees
When a promoter receives a quotation for a TEV assignment,
the first thing to check should be the scope rather than only the amount.
TEV report fees normally relate to the professional work
involved in assessing the technical and economic viability of a project. The
exact scope can differ depending on the project and lender, but a serious
assessment generally looks at several connected areas.
The technical side considers whether the proposed project
can actually be implemented as planned. This may involve production capacity,
technology, machinery, utilities, raw materials, location, implementation
schedule and the proposed operating arrangement.
The economic and financial side looks at whether the project
can generate sufficient returns and cash flows. Project cost, means of finance,
revenue assumptions, operating expenses, working capital, profitability, cash
flows and debt servicing are normally important parts of the assessment.
A lender is interested in how these pieces fit together.
For example, a promoter may say that a new manufacturing
unit will produce 10,000 units a month. The consultant has to consider whether
the proposed machinery supports that capacity, whether the production ramp up
is reasonable, whether there is sufficient market demand and whether the
projected sales can support the cost structure.
Financial analysis may include indicators such as DSCR, IRR,
break even levels and projected cash flows where relevant.
A proper TEV assessment can also identify assumptions that
require further clarification. That is useful before the proposal reaches the
credit committee because resolving inconsistencies at that stage is usually
easier than responding to repeated lender queries later.
The fee may also cover discussions with the promoter, review
of documents, analysis of existing operations, examination of project estimates
and preparation of the final report.
If a site visit, technical verification or lender specific
requirements are included, these should be clearly mentioned in the engagement
scope.
This is particularly important for larger projects. A
promoter should know whether the quoted TEV report fees include only a desktop
assessment or involve field level review as well.
7. Why the Cheapest TEV Report May Not Be the Best Option
Cost matters. Nobody wants to pay unnecessarily high
professional fees.
But with a TEV report, looking only at the lowest quotation
can create problems later.
Suppose two consultants quote substantially different TEV
report fees for the same industrial project. At first glance, the lower
quotation may appear attractive.
But are both consultants doing the same work?
One may be offering a limited financial assessment based
mainly on promoter supplied information. The other may be reviewing the
technical proposal, project cost, machinery quotations, operating assumptions,
market information and lender requirements in greater detail.
The reports may have the same title, but the underlying work
may not be comparable.
This is something I have seen cause frustration for
promoters. A report is prepared quickly, submitted to the lender, and then
several basic questions come back. The promoter assumes the bank is
unnecessarily delaying the proposal. Sometimes the lender is simply asking
questions that should have been addressed during the original assessment.
A low fee is not automatically a problem. For a
straightforward assignment with clear documentation, a reasonable professional
fee may be perfectly appropriate.
The concern arises when the scope is too narrow for the
project.
A promoter should ideally ask:
What information will be reviewed?
Will the consultant examine the project cost?
Will technical assumptions be assessed?
Will financial projections be tested?
Is sensitivity analysis included where required?
Are lender specific requirements covered?
Is a site visit required?
Will clarification be provided after submission to the
lender?
What happens if the bank raises questions about the report?
These questions make the comparison more meaningful.
There is also a misconception that a TEV report is primarily
a document created to satisfy a bank. It is better viewed as an independent
assessment that can expose weaknesses in the project before the lender does.
That can save money.
If a ₹100 crore expansion has a flawed working capital
assumption, discovering it before financial closure is far less painful than
discovering it after the project has started.
Sometimes perfectly good projects get delayed because
documentation was prepared in the wrong sequence. It still surprises me.
8. When Banks and Lenders Ask for a Detailed TEV Assessment
Banks and financial institutions may ask for a TEV
assessment when they need greater independent comfort regarding the feasibility
of a project.
The requirement is not identical for every loan proposal.
A small machinery loan for an established business may not
require the same level of assessment as a large greenfield project.
For a major project, the lender needs to understand what is
being financed and how the borrower expects the debt to be repaid.
Consider a solar project seeking long term project finance.
The lender may want an assessment of the project configuration, capital
expenditure, generation assumptions, operating costs, revenue arrangement and
debt servicing capacity.
Now consider a hospital project.
The lender may need to examine bed capacity, construction
cost, medical equipment, staffing, occupancy assumptions, treatment mix,
operating expenses and projected cash generation.
A warehouse expansion can present a different set of
questions. The lender may be interested in construction costs, storage
capacity, expected utilisation, rental or operating revenue, location and
repayment capacity.
For a manufacturing expansion, the focus may shift towards
installed capacity, utilisation, machinery, raw material availability, customer
demand, production costs and incremental working capital.
A detailed TEV assessment becomes particularly relevant
when:
- The
project involves substantial capital expenditure.
- The
proposal is greenfield.
- The
technical configuration is complex.
- The
lender needs independent technical and financial assessment.
- Multiple
lenders are involved.
- The
promoter is seeking significant term debt.
- Project
assumptions require closer examination.
- The
project is being restructured or revived.
- The
lender has specifically asked for a TEV report.
- There
are material gaps between the DPR, financial projections and other
submitted documents.
In lending situations, the report is only one part of the
overall credit appraisal.
The bank may also assess the promoter's track record,
existing financial position, banking conduct, security, contribution, repayment
capacity and other internal credit parameters.
So even a well prepared TEV report does not mean loan
approval is guaranteed.
Its purpose is to give the lender a credible basis for
assessing project viability.
9. How Frontline Consultants Approaches TEV Assignments
Frontline Consultants has been working in financial and
project advisory for more than 30 years. Its experience covers assignments
connected with lenders, industrial projects, corporate borrowers and promoters.
The practical approach to a TEV assignment starts with
understanding the project rather than immediately filling a report format.
For an existing manufacturing company seeking expansion
finance, the first requirement is usually an understanding of the current
business. Historical financial performance, existing capacity, utilisation,
product mix, proposed machinery, incremental investment and expected additional
revenue all matter.
For a greenfield project, the approach is different.
There may be no operating history. The assessment therefore
has to pay closer attention to project cost, technical feasibility,
implementation schedule, market assumptions, funding structure and projected
operations.
The same applies to sector specific assignments.
A solar project cannot be assessed using exactly the same
assumptions as a hospital. An infrastructure project has different risks from
an industrial warehouse. A restructuring case has a different purpose from a
new project seeking first time financing.
Frontline Consultants' wider project advisory experience
includes Techno Economic Viability Reports, Lenders Independent Engineer
Services, Agency for Special Monitoring, Detailed Project Reports, Enterprise
Valuation, Asset Valuation, Credit Syndication, Debt Restructuring, Bank
Liaison, Project Advisory and Business Financial Consulting.
That broader exposure can be useful because project
viability rarely sits in isolation.
A project may be technically sound but financially
stretched.
A business may have strong demand but insufficient working
capital.
A promoter may have a viable expansion plan but an
unrealistic implementation schedule.
A project may appear profitable on paper but have weak debt
servicing capacity because cash flows are poorly timed.
These distinctions matter during lender discussions.
The objective should not be to make every project appear
attractive. An independent assessment should identify where the proposal is
strong and where assumptions need attention.
If something appears weak, it is better for the promoter to
know before approaching the lender.
That is also where the discussion around TEV report fees
becomes more sensible. The professional fee should be considered alongside the
scope, level of analysis, project complexity and support expected from the
consultant.
10. Frequently Asked Questions About TEV Report Fees
What are TEV report fees?
TEV report fees are the professional charges for preparing a
Techno Economic Viability assessment. The amount depends on factors such as
project size, sector, complexity, documentation, technical requirements and
lender expectations.
Is there a fixed TEV report fee in India?
There is no single fee applicable to every project. A small
expansion assignment and a large greenfield infrastructure project can require
very different levels of professional work.
What affects TEV report fees the most?
Project complexity, project cost, greenfield or expansion
status, quality of available information, technical requirements, financial
structure and lender specific requirements can all influence the fee.
Do TEV report fees include financial analysis?
In a properly scoped TEV assignment, financial analysis is
generally an important part of the assessment. This can include project cost,
means of finance, projected profitability, cash flows and debt servicing
indicators where relevant.
Do TEV report fees include a site visit?
Not necessarily. It depends on the engagement scope. If a
lender requires physical verification or the project circumstances make a site
visit appropriate, it should be specifically discussed before the assignment
begins.
Can a TEV report help with bank financing?
Yes, a TEV report can support the lender's assessment of
project feasibility and repayment capacity. However, it does not guarantee loan
approval because banks consider several other credit parameters.
Should an MSME always get a TEV report before applying
for finance?
Not every MSME financing proposal requires a detailed TEV
assessment. The need depends on the size and nature of the project, the funding
requirement and the lender's requirements.
Can Frontline Consultants prepare TEV reports for
manufacturing projects?
Yes. Frontline Consultants undertakes Techno Economic
Viability assignments for industrial and other project requirements, with the
scope determined by the nature of the project and the lender's expectations.
Why do TEV report fees differ between consultants?
Different consultants may be offering different levels of
analysis, verification, documentation review and post submission support.
Comparing the scope of work is therefore more useful than comparing only the
quoted fee.
What should I ask before accepting a TEV quotation?
Ask what the fee covers, what documents will be reviewed,
whether technical and financial assumptions will be examined, whether a site
visit is included, what lender requirements are covered and whether
clarification support is available after submission.
